If medical debts are removed from credit reports, there could be several issues:
- Incomplete Credit History: Credit reports would no longer reflect all of a person’s financial obligations. This means lenders might not have a full picture of someone’s ability to manage and repay debts.
- Risk Assessment Challenges: Lenders use credit reports to assess the risk of lending money. Without information on medical debts, they might find it harder to accurately gauge this risk, potentially leading to more cautious lending practices.
- Higher Interest Rates: To compensate for the lack of information, lenders might increase interest rates for everyone. This could make loans and credit more expensive, even for those with good credit histories.
- Reduced Incentive to Pay: If unpaid medical debts don’t affect credit scores, some people might be less motivated to pay them. This could lead to higher default rates on medical bills.
- Impact on Healthcare Providers: Hospitals and medical professionals might struggle to collect unpaid bills. This could affect their financial stability and possibly lead to increased healthcare costs to offset the losses.
- Fairness Issues: People who have worked hard to pay off their medical debts might feel it’s unfair that others who haven’t paid face no credit consequences.
- Alternative Data Sources: Lenders might start using other, less regulated sources of information to assess creditworthiness. This could raise privacy concerns and potentially include inaccurate data.
- Strain on the Credit System: The overall reliability of the credit reporting system could decrease if significant types of debt are excluded, affecting its effectiveness in the financial industry.
Background:Small Debt Exclusion: Starting in 2023, medical collection debts under $500 are excluded from credit reports. Extended Reporting Time: The time before unpaid medical collection debt appears on a credit report increased from 6 months to 1 year. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) has proposed a rule ( supported by Biden administration and Kamala Harris) that would eliminate the special medical debt exception, which currently allows lenders to obtain and use information about medical debt in making credit eligibility determinations. While this ( if it becomes a reality) change would undoubtedly provide much-needed relief to patients struggling with medical expenses, it’s important to recognize that the government’s current approach to implementing this policy may not effectively address the root causes of medical debt and could introduce new challenges for the financial system. Fact: America’s medical system is broken ! |
By considering these factors, it’s clear that removing medical debts from credit reports could have unintended negative effects on both individuals and the broader financial system.