Have been trying to shortlist a Debt Collection Agency by looking at their Google reviews or Yelp rating? According to inc.com – 88% of customers read an online review, and that influenced their buying decision. But, a single bad review can undo the value of 40 good customer experiences.
Those online review methodologies work well for restaurants and doctors, but the same criteria does not work well for the Debt Collections industry.
- Most negative reviews are left by debtors who hate debt collectors anyway. That is because the Collection Agency recovered some money from them, which they were not planning to pay.
- Some disgruntled employees who were unable to adapt with the pressure of being a Debt Collector leave a negative review about the job or the workplace. May be they were unable to make enough money as a debt collector and left a negative online Google review.
- Many clients submit highly disputed debts to a collection agency and expect that those debts will somehow be magically recovered. If a debt is highly disputed or too old, even a collection agency may not be able to recover those. No collection agency will recover 100% of the debts assigned.
- Not many clients who get good returns take the pain to leave a review for a Collections Agency on Google or Yelp? Not may clients want to publically announce online that they use the services of a collection agency. Some clients who do leave positive reviews do so because their Collection Agency Rep requested them to do so. Dissatisfied customers are more vocal, and so are the debtors.
- Many businesses, including collection agencies, often hire “Reputation management firms” and marketing firms to ensure good online ratings, which has almost nothing to do with the real recovery rates of that collection agency. They attempt to game the online review system.
We are not saying that there is no way to gauge a collection agency, but due to the nature of the job they perform, they simply cannot be evaluated by general public reviews.
Many people from the accounts receivable industry crack joke by saying that it is quite possible that a Collection Agency with horrible ratings on Google could indeed be the best one (since it recovered so much money, it landed up annoying too many people). We are not recommending you to use this judgement criteria either.
Many agencies which are rated higher on Google, do so by requesting their employees, friends and only satisfied customers to leave 5-star reviews and therefore artificially raise their ratings. Unlike sites like Amazon, where we have a “Verified Buyer” tag next to a review, generic online reviews like those on Google/Yelp have no way to know whether the reviewer has even used a service or if the reviewer is a debtor, employee or someone else. Therefore these reviews are subjected to manipulation.
Some agencies simply try to push their ratings higher to take benefits of Search Engine Optimization. However, some agencies are genuinely rated higher, but we are talking very broadly. Better Business Bureau (BBB) ratings are probably more reliable.
The right way to gauge a collection agency is by their recovery rates, product offerings, adherence to the debt collection laws and the experience of their management and staff.
The medical industry uses Collection Agencies a lot, may you have a friend who is a doctor, he can recommend a good collection agency.
Contact us for your debt collection needs.